The Hunger Games novel is the first book in a series of three which has been turned into a major motion movie released during the last couple of the weeks. I went to see the movie and have read the three novels. Now don’t get me wrong I loved the movie but I don’t think it lived up to the standards of the novel. This means I loved the movie as a movie and novel as a novel. The movie did not live up to my expectations as the film missed out parts of the story line, the casting and costuming didn't fit the description exactly of the book. However the film did cover the main incidents of the book in order, and it did entertain me as a movie. In this blog I am going to cover how the book was adapted into the movie through:
·
Storyline
·
Costuming
·
Casting
Also I look at what
the trailer made me think of the movie.
Before I started this
blog I looked at a review on the movie by Lisa Kothari on the site Seattle PI. I have quoted
throughout this blog as I found it quite useful and it challenged my opinions
of the film.
Katniss and Gale |
Storyline:
When the movie started both my dad and I agreed it missed out most of
the facts on Katniss’s relationships with the people in her district. Therefore her relationships are not
completely portrayed in the film. For example the directors did not allow
enough time for the relationship between Katniss and Gale to be fully shown. In
the novel Gale is like an older brother in Katniss’s eyes however he sees
Katniss in a different way. Gale has a crush on Katniss but this is not shown
in the film. When we see Katniss kissing Paeta during the games we see Gale's
reaction but you wouldn’t understand his reaction unless you had read the book
and knew the full story of their relationship. Also when Katniss is saying good
bye to her mum she says “you can’t zone out again, you just can’t. You’re all
she has” Katniss is saying this as when her father died her mother stopped
doing anything for her sister and herself. Katniss ended up fending for her
sister and providing for her, at a young age therefore she did not get on well with her mother as her
mother did nothing to help keep food in her and her sisters mouths and clothes
on their bodies. Also the review said "the movie does run
true to the book, even if a lot of the story is skipped quickly over or left
out altogether, the cast members bring to life the characters authentically,
and you do get a chance to see the action you had only conjured up mentally
while reading. I prefer the book, although I did like seeing the film – I just
wish it would have embraced the themes and outrageousness of the story more
authentically. In that sense, it missed the mark for me." and for me that was the same. As I absolutely loved the
books and when I heard the first one was becoming a movie I was over the moon.
And I believe that it did follow true to the book but it did not provide the
full message and horror of the events.
Saying this, the movie did follow all the main events in the story. Such
as it went from her hunting in the forest to being at the reaping; from saying
goodbye to family to being on the train with Peeta; to training to being in the
games. And during the games everything went as per book. The review I read said
" the movie was very
good overall. In particular, I liked how the games followed the sequence and
action in the book." because even though they missed little
details the audience still gets the idea of the main story line. As the movie
followed the main events of the book and had a good story line it entertained me.
Costuming:
Effie Trinket |
When I first saw Effie Trinket I was slightly disappointed by her
looks because in the book she has a "scary white grin, pinkish
hair" and she wore a "spring green suit". However in the movie she didn't quite appear
the way I thought she should but that is just my personal opinion. Also when we
first see Katniss she is reasonably well dressed in quite nice clothes. I feel
this contradicts the book as she struggles to earn money to feed her family and
put food on the table. Therefore, I do not think the costuming was fully
portrayed in the movie as it was in the book.
Casting:
Many people are debating whether Jennifer Laurence is skinny
enough to play Katniss or not. For example Mr Pulland believes she does not
look like she is starving and I agree with him. Another website looks at this 'weight issue' and says "conversation around
the film of late has zeroed in on star Jennifer Lawrence’s body: that,
ahem, she didn’t look hungry enough for the starring role." Therefore I wonder whether Jennifer Laurence was the right person to
play Katniss as she is supposed to be rather skinny with hardly any meat on
their bones. However the main review I read said "I thought the actors
were well-suited to their characters" which contrasts other views. Showing me that there is quite a debate on
the fact of whether Laurence was the right person to cast for the character of
Katniss Everdeen or not.
Trailer:
When I first saw this trailer for the film I was excited that the book
was finally becoming a movie. I also feel the trailer was a bit of a letdown as
over half the trailer shows parts from less than the first half of the film and
only shows the start of the games. If it
had shown parts of the games all jumbled together it would made the movie more
inviting. But that's my opinion.
In conclusion, I feel that the film is a good film and followed the main
storyline of the book. However the movie did not live up to my expectations as
it missed out parts of the story and the casting and costuming didn't fit
the descriptions in the book according to me.